Would I say that it was worth the time and money that I invested? Absolutely. Not only do they look much better, but they actually stay on and are much easier to spot that my ugly homemade ones. They also save me time since I'm not re-labelling every week - they are washer-, dryer- and dishwasher-safe.
I'll spare you the details, but basically I ended up buying from two Canadian companies - Mabel's Labels and Oliver's Labels. My favourite was the latter, but there was one product that I really liked from Mabel's that Oliver's didn't carry.
For those of you who have kids, I highly recommend Oliver's labels. They are high quality, visually appealing labels with many designs to choose from and are fairly priced. Also, they have
a recovery system (optional) whereby you can get a unique ID printed on your labels such that if someone finds your child's shoe/item/bottle etc., it can easily be returned to you.In fact, I like them so much that I signed up to be their agent! Here's a link to their site - please make sure to mention my name if you do order from them.